Family & Friends

  • Nov
  • 4

Using Animals

Posted by at 3:52 PM | Permalink | Comments (5)


“But what’s wrong with using animals as long as they are treated humanely?” How many times have you heard someone ask this question? Most people agree on the value of humane treatment, but using animals inevitably leads to abusing animals.

Let’s look at animals used for food. Nearly all animals raised for food in the U.S. live on factory farms. There’s a simple reason for this: It’s cheaper. More animals can be raised per dollar on an industrial farm than on a small farm, where each animal gets outdoor access and individual care. Sure, many animals sicken and die from the crowded and filthy conditions on factory farms, but it’s still far more cost effective for meat, egg, and dairy producers to raise animals this way.

Think about it from the farmer’s perspective. If your competitor is producing pig or chicken meat in huge warehouses of closely confined animals, his costs will be lower than your costs to raise those same animals in more humane conditions. Even if you genuinely care about the animals on your farm, you still have to pay your mortgage and put food on your family’s table. You can reject the confinement system in favor of something better for the animals—and you might be able to charge a premium for the resulting meat, dairy products, or eggs—but where will you draw the line? If you produce eggs or dairy products, what will you do with the male offspring of your hens or cows? They’re useless to you as replacement animals, and their value as meat animals is low since they haven’t been bred for that purpose. Can you afford to give all these male animals a lifetime of easy living on your farm? Can you pay for their food and veterinary care even though they generate no income for you? Even “humane” farmers won’t do this because the cost is prohibitive.

Cattle raised for their flesh are usually castrated and branded. Pigs are also castrated and often have their ears mutilated for identification. As a “humane” farmer, you can ignore common ranching practice and provide your animals with pain relief for these procedures. But you’ll be competing with others who aren’t spending those dollars, which will come straight out of your profits. And remember that even “humanely” raised animals must endure the same horrors during their transport and slaughter as their factory-farmed cousins.

Here’s another point for a “humane” farmer to consider. Most modern breeds of chickens, turkeys, pigs, and cows used for dairy products are genetically engineered for maximum production. That leads to all kinds of health problems—including heart disease, infections, and bone fractures—caused by their rapid growth and abnormally large size. These animals must be killed at a young age or face crippling disabilities as they get too large. Farmers can choose so-called “heritage” breeds of animals with less-altered genetics, but they will get less “product” out of each animal. And they still must kill them at a young age for maximum profit—after all, animal feed is expensive! Farmers can eliminate some abuses, but if they’re in business to make money, they must make trade-offs that are not in their animals’ best interests.

What about using animals as experimental subjects in a laboratory? Conditions in labs are inherently stressful and frightening for animals, and the experiments themselves are often painful or lethal. Pain relief may not be used if there’s a risk of its altering the experimental data. While some labs claim to follow animal-care protocols, a few “enrichment” toys in a monkey’s barren cage are no substitute for the community of family and friends that he or she would enjoy in a natural environment. As with animals raised for food, animals used in labs suffer greatly no matter how “humane” the policies of the individual lab. And using animals to study human diseases is not even good science.

What about companion animals? Can’t we use dogs and cats for companionship without its leading to abuse? Our track record isn’t very good here either. How many dog and cat breeders offer lifelong care to the animals they breed who don’t fit a customer’s standards or who are unable to find loving, permanent homes? While some may, market economics will ensure that they are always in the minority. Their competitors are puppy mills and “backyard breeders,” cranking out “pedigree” animals at the lowest possible cost. Dog and cat breeders, no matter how well-intentioned, contribute to our dog and cat overpopulation problem and ensure that many unwanted animals will be euthanized in severely crowded animal shelters.

There is no humane way to use an animal. When people’s goals conflict with animals’ needs, the animals are the losers. Reducing costs and increasing profits are powerful motivators even for the best-intentioned animal custodians. The question of use and abuse goes away only when we put the needs of animals first by advocating for a world in which animals are allowed to live for their own purposes.

Posted to Family & Friends | Posted to Tags: , , , ,

More:

Bookmark and Share
5 Comments

Subscribe to this post's comment RSS.

    Jan Glancy says...

    November 4th, 2011, 5:20 pm

    How elegantly stated. It really is simple. I may use this to inform those who ask about my veganism. It is polite and to the point and covers all the uses and abuses except circuses and entertainment.
    Jan

    Chrisxxx says...

    November 4th, 2011, 6:38 pm

    Also, animals used for sports are abused. I’ve read that dogs and horses who outlive their ability to be profitable in the racing world are destroyed. Then there is always the horiffic dog and chicken fighting world. As you stated, all animals should be “allowed to live for their own purposes.” Great article, thanks.

    Jeff says...

    November 4th, 2011, 11:49 pm

    Most of this article is very well stated and I agree with, but the last section about companionship animals has one flaw in the thinking. The idea that companionship is “using” the animal for our purposes is a little misguided. Yes, I agree that mass breeding is a serious issue, but my three cats are all rescued from feral mothers and I consider them as my children, so I don’t agree that my animals are being “used” as much as a symbiotic relationship has been developed between us.

    Laura Guttridge says...

    November 5th, 2011, 11:04 am

    Excellent article.

    Pam says...

    November 10th, 2011, 2:19 pm

    My husband and i have a little Border Terrier that has a very good life.If i was granted one wish it would be for animals of all shapes and sizes not be exploited.We need to strengthen the animal rights law to protect these poor creatures from the hands of greedy humans.Our population growth brings with it greed and exploitation of any and everything that gets in the paths of the wrong people.I chose to become a vegetarian on earth day this year and now after reading more about the conditions that dairy animals and chickens live in most likely will not be buying eggs,cheese or mild.Wow i give up food i love so people can continue their gluttony.:o(

Post a Comment

Please keep comments polite, constructive, and on topic. All fields in bold are required.

About Family & Friends

Make your time with your friends and family—including your animal companions—even more meaningful.

Recent Comments

Disclaimer

The information and views provided here are intended for informational and preliminary educational purposes only. From time to time, content may be posted on the site regarding various financial planning and human and animal health issues. Such content is never intended to be and should never be taken as a substitute for the advice of readers' own financial planners, veterinarians, or other licensed professionals. You should not use any information contained on this site to diagnose yourself or your companion animals' health or fitness. Readers in need of applicable professional advice are strongly encouraged to seek it. Except where third-party ownership or copyright is indicated or credited regarding materials contained in this blog, reproduction or redistribution of any of the content for personal, noncommercial use is enthusiastically encouraged.